top of page

Social Media, Child Custody Battles and Parental Rights; Do They Mix? 

A child looks sad as parents argue behind her

In a recent decision, the Arizona Court of Appeals overturned a trial court order that restricted parents from posting about their child's medical, physical, mental, behavioral, educational, or related issues on social media without written consent from the other parent or a court order. This ruling has important implications for parental rights and First Amendment freedoms. 

Case Background 

The case arose from a dispute between parents over a social media post by the father. He posted a video of their child having a seizure, claiming he was seeking help for the child's condition. The mother argued that the video violated the child's privacy rights. This disagreement led to a trial court order preventing both parents from posting any information about their child online. 

First Amendment Concerns 

The Court of Appeals reviewed the order as a prior restraint on speech, which typically faces strict scrutiny under First Amendment law. The appellate court highlighted the need to protect free speech rights while considering potential harm to the child. 

Narrowly Tailored Restrictions 

The Court of Appeals found the trial court's order overly broad, as it banned all social media posts about the child, not just those related to the seizure. The appellate court stressed that any restriction must be narrowly tailored and use the least restrictive means to prevent harm. 

Implications for Parents 

This ruling highlights the balance between protecting a child's privacy and upholding parents' free speech rights. Parents should be mindful that while they can share information about their children, they must do so responsibly. Broad restrictions that infringe on First Amendment rights are unlikely to stand. 

Seeking Legal Guidance   

Family law and constitutional rights can be complex. If you're facing similar issues or have questions about your parental rights, it's crucial to get expert legal advice. 

Contact Simon Law Group PLLC today for a free consultation and to learn more about your legal options 

Protecting Your Rights 

At Simon Law Group PLLC, we understand the importance of both protecting your child's privacy and your rights. Our experienced attorneys are here to help you navigate these sensitive issues and provide the support you need. 

Don't wait – schedule your free consultation with Simon Law Group PLLC today and let us help you protect your rights and your family's privacy. 

Wrapping the Case Up 

The Arizona Court of Appeals' decision serves as a reminder of the need to balance parental rights and child privacy within the framework of the First Amendment. Parents should be careful when sharing information about their children online, ensuring they respect their child's privacy rights while exercising free speech. 

For personalized legal advice and support, reach out to Simon Law Group PLLC. Schedule your free consultation online today and let us guide you through your child custody struggles.  


bottom of page